What one game would you keep if you're stuck all alone on an island?

[Bloo]

yay, then you could put DIFFERENT little icon thingies for the hud :P

seriously though, if you could download mods, surely you'd be able to download indie games? or just use warez or steam and get everything you could wish for. It would be slow, but then again, you'd have time. :P

Very true, but it does kind of miss the point of the question as well.