I don't understand how FIFA won Sports Game of the Year or the Online Element. If it's games released in the UK, then it should be NHL 10, because that game is incredible. The online features in FIFA and most of the EA Sports games last year were emulated from the succes from NHL 09, which won nearly every single sports game award in the US this time last year. But I still maintain the best sports game overall is the MLB: The Show series, but that's only out in the US, and MLB 10: The Show on my shopping list in April.
And I have no idea why Arkham won Best Game. It was an alright game, but there were so many brilliant games last year that were way better. I haven't played it, but apparently Uncharted 2 is ace (as shown above with 3 awards) and probably deserved it more.
Bookmarks